Immigrant Worker Ethics Essay - 1713 Words

INTRODUCTION The purpose of this report is to discuss my opinion on the question â€Å"Do I agree with the recommendations of the Human Rights Watch (HRW) in regards to work safety particularly when it comes to immigrant workers?† I will provide information on past and current safety related issues as they apply to the meat packing industry and immigrant workers. I will discuss the recommendations of the HRW. I will provide my opinion and consider some of the utilitarian and deontological considerations, and conclude this report with a brief summary of the entire analysis, highlighting some of the most significant parts that the report contains HISTORY â€Å"In 1906, Upton Sinclairs novel The Jungle uncovered harrowing conditions inside†¦show more content†¦In 1988, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) fined IBP for exposing its employees to trauma disorders from repetitive meat cutting tasks. IBP knew of the hazards but did nothing to correct them. IMMIGRANT MIGRATION One in every fifty human beings – more than 150 million persons – live outside their countries of origin as migrants or refugees. They are highly vulnerable to racism, and discrimination. The fact that an increasing proportion of international migration today is irregular and unauthorized facilitates abuse and exploitation. But, even when their movements are legal and authorized, non-citizens face high levels of discrimination. Immigrants both legal and illegal make up 13% of the nation’s workers, the highest percentage since the 1930s. They dominate job categories at both ends of the economic spectrum. Immigrants hold 35% of the unskilled jobs. It is not that Americans are not afraid of doing hard work; they are just unwilling to put themselves at risk of losing an eye or finger for minimum wages. In fact â€Å"most of the nations 17.7 million immigrant workers toil, like those who preceded them, in jobs that native-born Americans refuse to do. They work as meatpackers, hotel maids, hamburger flippers, waiters, gardeners, seamstresses, fruit and vegetable pickers, and construction hands. (USA Today, 2001) Immigrants, above all illegal immigrants, can not defend themselves against abusiveShow MoreRelatedCreating A Culture Of Tolerance And Acceptance Of Differences949 Words   |  4 Pagesof new immigrants if they provide cultural awareness and sensitivity training to help create a culture of tolerance and acceptance of differences. Position I will present: New immigrants should integrate into the American population and take advantage of the American culture which has led on average, internationally, in labor productivity. Employers can help more than they have helped to ensure that immigrants achieve this objective of integration to maximize productivity. Audience: Immigrant CommunityRead MoreJonathan Klemens s The Protestant Work Ethic : Just Another Urban Legend?979 Words   |  4 Pages Jonathan Klemens s in his essay â€Å"The Protestant Work Ethic: Just Another Urban Legend?† claims that the American work ethic, despite many saying otherwise, is still deeply rooted in American society. He states that this work ethic is personified in the persons who find their work both personally enjoying and a service to society. In other words, people who have found their passion. He goes on to explain that this dedication to hard work is exemplified by the existence of societies such as theRead MoreJohn Steinbeck s Harvest Gypsies 1664 Words   |  7 Pagesaddresses in The Jungle, industry workers were refused the basic human rights that the government vowed to protect. Harvest Gypsies, written by John Steinbeck just 30 years later, brought rural farmers’ grievances into the picture after their land was destroyed during the Dust Bowl. The rhetoric used in these works criticizes the exploitative working environment in response to a strong capitalist agenda, discourages the separation of classes caused by the ‘Protestant Ethic’, and attempts to humanizeRead Moreillegal immigrant workers should be granted legal status1347 Words   |  6 Pagesone position on â€Å"illegal immigrant workers should be granted legal status† For the past 120 years- â€Å"between 1891 and 1920- [America has] received some 18 million men, women and children from other nations† (Bush 554) and causes one of the serious problem in the society. Therefore, immigration reform has been intensely debate among the citizen due to illegal immigrant issues that have become prevalent in United States. However, validating the illegal immigrant workers status should be consideredRead MoreImmigration Policy And Its Impact On America882 Words   |  4 Pagessignificance of its impact in America. Many of the values that brings America together as a nation, is due to immigration. America is a melting pot of variety of people that brings great contribution to the growth and transformation in the workforce. Immigrants has been strengthen America s economy every since the 18th century American industrial revolution. During the American industrial revolution, it offers a great opportunity for people outside of the border for investment, employment, and productivityRead MoreImmigration And The United States1177 Words   |  5 PagesThen, immigrants must fill out the official naturalization application called the N400 form. Within this form, there are several questions asking about the immigrant’s life, family, employment, and criminal background. After completion, immigrants must send in the N400 form with a passport and application fee. Next, the immigrant has to have his or her fingerprints taken and participate in an interview. If the application is approved, the immigrant will then take the Oath of Allegiance to the UnitedRead MoreThe Latino : Hard Work Essay1470 Words   |  6 Pagesthe United States, but undocumented workers are often faced with complex adversities and obstacles that extend beyond their cultural understanding, hindering them from true upward social mobility in the United States. Language, destitution, and cultural upbringings are commonly observed things that contribute to the adversities challenging undocumented workers ability to socially grow when immigrating to the United States. The majority of Latino undocumented workers are presently part of the labor forceRead MoreIllegal Immigrants Should NOT be Deported Essay example916 Words   |  4 Pagespresident Chester A. Aurthor was the first president to bann all chinese workers. Soon after, the criminals and the mentally ill were refused from theU.S. Immigration wasnt always a problem before this. In 1892 the first portal oft immigration opened up in Ellis Island, New York. This was the premier station for immigration. Here new arrivals had to show identity and were asked a series of questions. After all this the immigrants were scanned for physical ailments and they had to have a friend or familyRead MoreChanging Up The Center Of America1075 Words   |  5 PagesChanging up the Center To be an immigrant coming into America must be so hard in many ways, but as the people of America we should do something to help, by making the Krome Detention Center a better place. Once Immigrants are in America and are at Krome Detention Center, they should start learning the basics of English, learning work ethic, and learning social skills. Once Immigrants have learned all the basic skills, and have been approved for their permanent residence card or temporary card, thenRead MoreAsian American And Asian Americans964 Words   |  4 PagesMany Asian Americans take great pride in a strong work ethic and an equally strong value system in terms of educational achievement. This cultural legacy stems from a long tradition of Asians coming into America as immigrants since the 19th century. During this time, there are third and fourth generation Asian Americans that have adopted the principles of a quality education and strong work ethic as part of being of Asian descent in a primarily white Anglo-American population. Culturally, many Asians